An annuity is a contract between a buyer and an insurance company: the buyer makes one or more premium payments, and the insurer makes income payments for life or for a defined period. Under California law, an annuity is an insurance product that is individually solicited, regardless of whether it is classified as individual or group. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.913(a).)
What Is an Annuity?
An annuity is a contract between you and an insurance company. You buy the annuity by making one or more premium payments—the money you pay is also called your principal. The insurance company then makes income payments to you, either for life or for a defined period.
Annuities usually have commissions and other fees that reduce the amount working for you. Most people who buy an annuity do so to receive income in retirement. Because of the long time horizon and the costs involved, the California Department of Insurance (CDI) describes an annuity as a long-term investment and advises consumers to make the decision carefully.
California law defines an annuity as an insurance product that is individually solicited, regardless of whether it is classified as an individual or group annuity. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.913(a).)
Types of Annuities Available in California
California consumers will encounter several distinct annuity structures. The CDI describes the main categories as follows.
Variable annuity. The insurance company invests the annuity in stocks, bonds, or other investments based on the level of risk the buyer chooses. If those investments perform poorly, the buyer may lose some or all of the investment.
Fixed annuity. The buyer's money earns interest at rates set by the insurer, or in another way described in the contract. The interest rate may be set for one year or for up to ten years. A fixed annuity is generally considered the more conservative structure because the rate is contractually defined rather than market-driven.
Equity-indexed (fixed indexed) annuity. This is a type of fixed annuity whose interest rate is usually based on a stock market index. The contract carries a contractually stated minimum interest rate, but the insurer determines how much above that minimum the buyer actually receives. A buyer does not capture all stock-market gains. The CDI cautions consumers to watch for fixed annuities with a minimum stated interest rate of 0%: the buyer will not lose principal, but the money will not grow, and the buyer will not receive all the extra interest the stock market might earn. A fixed indexed annuity combines index-linked potential with a contractual floor.
Immediate annuity. Income payments begin within one year of purchase. The buyer usually cannot withdraw extra money. The primary purpose is to receive a regular income right away in retirement. A single premium immediate annuity is the most common form.
Deferred annuity. Income payments begin many years later. The primary purpose is tax-deferred growth—meaning taxes on earnings are postponed until withdrawals begin—during the accumulation period.
A note on teaser rates. Some annuities offer a higher stated interest rate for the first year only. This is called a teaser rate—a promotional rate that decreases after the introductory period. The CDI advises consumers to ask what the minimum rate is and how long any higher rate lasts.
The two periods of a deferred annuity
Deferred annuities have two distinct phases:
- Accumulation period: The period when the money grows. It can last for more than ten years.
- Amortization period: The period when income payments are made. It can last as long as the buyer's life and, in some contracts, the life of a beneficiary.
A multi-year guarantee annuity is a common form of deferred fixed annuity with a rate locked for a defined term.
Surrender Charges and Access to Your Money
If a buyer needs money during the accumulation period of a deferred annuity, a penalty called a surrender charge typically applies. A surrender charge is a fee the insurer deducts when a buyer withdraws funds or cancels the contract before the accumulation period ends.
The CDI states that surrender charges can be high and that a buyer may end up with less money than they started with. No money can be taken out in the first year; after that, some money may be withdrawn without a penalty up to a limit set by the contract. Withdrawals above that limit trigger the surrender charge.
For immediate annuities, the situation is different. After the 30-day free-look period (described in the next section), the buyer may not be able to recover the purchase payment except as annuity payments made according to the contract terms.
Estate planning consideration. If a buyer dies before income payments begin, the beneficiary may want to cash in the annuity. The CDI advises buyers to ask their agent whether the beneficiary would have to pay a surrender charge in that situation.
California disclosure requirement. California Insurance Code § 10127.13 requires that all individual annuity contracts for senior citizens that contain a surrender charge, partial-surrender charge, excess-withdrawal charge, or penalty upon surrender must include a notice disclosing the location of the charge, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information. That notice must appear in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page.