A surrender charge is the fee an insurance company charges if you take money out of your deferred annuity within a defined period stated in the contract. The California Department of Insurance (CDI) notes that the charge can be high and that the period can last as long as 10 years.
What Is an Annuity Surrender Charge?
The CDI defines a surrender charge as "the fee charged if you take money out of your deferred annuity within a certain period, such as 10 years," and states plainly that "the surrender charge can be high."
Surrender charges apply to deferred annuities — contracts where income payments start at least one year in the future, and usually many years out. They do not apply to immediate annuities, which begin paying income within a year of purchase.
The charge can be triggered in more than one way. Depending on your contract, it may apply to a full surrender (cashing out the entire contract), a partial surrender (withdrawing a portion of the value), or an excess withdrawal (taking out more than the contract's free withdrawal allowance in a given year). Your contract states exactly which transactions trigger the charge and how it is calculated.
How the Surrender Charge Period Works
The surrender charge period is a defined term stated in your contract. It begins when the contract is issued and runs for a set number of years. During that window, taking money out beyond what the contract permits without a charge will cost you.
The CDI advises consumers to ask two specific questions before buying: "What is the surrender charge if I take out money early?" and "How long is the surrender charge period?" The CDI also recommends asking for a written list of all deadlines and surrender charges that apply if money is taken out early.
Surrender charges typically decline over the course of the surrender period — meaning the charge in year one is often higher than the charge in year eight — but the specific schedule is set by your individual contract. No two contracts are identical.
One practical reference point: the CDI's consumer guidance states that after the 30-day free-look period, "cancellation may result in a substantial penalty, known as a surrender charge." That language appears in the contract itself, as required by California law.
Free Withdrawal Allowances: Taking Money Out Without a Charge
Many deferred annuity contracts include a free withdrawal allowance — a provision that lets you withdraw a limited amount each year without triggering the surrender charge. The CDI notes that "you may be able to take out some money without paying a surrender charge," and recommends asking: "Can I take some money out without paying surrender charges and/or other charges? If yes, how much can I take out?"
The specific allowance — the dollar amount or percentage of contract value you may withdraw charge-free — is stated in your individual contract. Some contracts set the allowance as a percentage of the account value; others tie it to interest earned. Because the terms vary, reading your contract carefully, or having it reviewed, is the only way to know what applies to you.
If you withdraw more than the allowance in a contract year, the excess amount is generally subject to the surrender charge. Understanding where that line falls matters, especially if you anticipate needing access to funds during the surrender period.
California's Disclosure Requirements for Surrender Charges
California law sets specific notice requirements for annuity contracts sold to senior citizens. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10127.13, all individual annuity contracts for senior citizens that contain a charge upon surrender, partial surrender, excess withdrawal, or penalties upon surrender must include a notice disclosing the location of the charge, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information.
That notice must appear in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page of the policy. The statute also specifies that a policy shall have just one cover page, and that if the surrender-charge notice and the right-to-examine notice both appear on the cover page, they must appear on the same page.
This section became operative on July 1, 2015, and was amended effective January 1, 2016. If you hold a qualifying contract issued on or after that date, the surrender charge disclosure should be visible on the first page you see when you open your contract.
Minimum Nonforfeiture Values: The Floor on What You Can Receive
California law does not leave the surrender value entirely to the insurer's discretion. Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.4 establishes a floor: cash surrender benefits available prior to maturity shall not be less than the present value of the portion of the maturity value of the paid-up annuity benefit arising from considerations paid prior to surrender, reduced by prior withdrawals and indebtedness, and increased by any additional amounts credited. Critically, the statute states that the cash surrender benefit shall not be less than the minimum nonforfeiture amount at the time of surrender (Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.4(c)).
The minimum nonforfeiture amount itself is calculated under Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.25, which applies to contracts issued on and after January 1, 2006. The calculation starts with an accumulation of net considerations — defined as 87.5 percent of gross considerations credited in a contract year — and then reduces that amount by prior withdrawals, an annual contract charge of $50, any state premium tax paid by the company, and any indebtedness on the contract.
The interest rate used in that accumulation is the lesser of 3 percent per annum and a rate tied to the five-year Constant Maturity Treasury Rate, as specified in the statute. The details of the calculation are set by law, not by the insurer.
For a deeper look at how these floors are structured, the minimum nonforfeiture values page covers the statutory framework in full.
Death Benefit and Surrender Charges for Seniors
A separate California rule addresses what happens when a senior contract holder dies during the surrender period. For contracts issued or delivered on or after January 1, 2016, to persons who are 65 years of age or older, Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.4(d)(2) requires that the death benefit be at least equal to the annuity value or accumulation value, excluding any surrender charges or penalties upon death.
In practical terms, this means that for qualifying contracts, surrender charges cannot reduce the death benefit paid to a beneficiary below the accumulation value. The protection applies based on the age of the contract holder at the time the contract is issued or delivered, and on the contract's issue date.
If you hold a contract issued before January 1, 2016, or were under 65 when the contract was issued, the general rule under Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.4(d)(1) applies instead: the death benefit must be at least equal to the cash surrender benefit.
The 30-Day Free-Look Period for Seniors
The most complete protection against surrender charges is the free-look period. The CDI states that seniors have a 30-day free-look period — the right to examine the contract after purchase and return it for a full refund if you are not satisfied.
California law requires the contract to include this specific statement: "This policy may be returned within 30 days from the date you received it for a full refund by returning it to the insurance company or agent who sold you the policy. After the 30 days, cancellation may result in a substantial penalty, known as a surrender charge."
Within that 30-day window, no surrender charge applies. After it closes, the surrender charge schedule in your contract governs any early withdrawal. The free-look and cancellation page explains how to exercise that right and what the process involves.
Questions to Ask Before You Buy a Deferred Annuity
The CDI provides a checklist of questions every consumer should ask before purchasing a deferred annuity. On the topic of surrender charges, the CDI recommends asking:
- What is the surrender charge if I take out money early?
- How long is the surrender charge period?
- Can I take some money out without paying surrender charges, and if so, how much?
- Can you provide a written list of all deadlines and surrender charges if money is taken out early?
Beyond those specific questions, the CDI advises that before replacing an existing annuity with a new one, consumers are well served by receiving a full list of the benefits and drawbacks of doing so. Replacing a contract resets the surrender charge period, which can have significant consequences. The replacing an annuity page covers what California's replacement rules require.
The CDI also advises making sure the agent, broker, and insurance company are properly licensed before you buy. California's suitability rules for annuity sales set additional standards that apply to recommendations made to consumers, particularly seniors.
How to Verify a California-Licensed Insurer and File a Complaint
Before purchasing any annuity, the CDI recommends confirming that the insurance company is licensed by the California Department of Insurance. License verification is available at insurance.ca.gov or by calling the CDI at 1-800-927-4357.
If the insurance company is licensed in California, the annuity may be partially protected by the California Life & Health Insurance Guarantee Association. For more information on that protection, visit califega.org.
If you have a concern about how an annuity was sold to you, the CDI can help with issues including alleged misrepresentation by an agent or broker, dishonest or deceptive insurance sales tactics, and improper denial of a claim. To file a complaint or ask questions, call 1-800-927-4357 or visit insurance.ca.gov.