California law gives policyholders specific tools for this review. In the case of a policy designated as one for which illustrations will be used, insurers are required by statute to provide each policy owner with an annual report on the status of the policy. The California Department of Insurance (CDI) also publishes guidance on what to consider before making any changes to an existing policy.
What a Life Insurance Policy Review Is
A policy review is an examination of an existing life insurance policy to assess whether the coverage still aligns with the policyholder's current circumstances. It is not a sales process. It is a structured look at the facts of the policy as it stands today.
The CDI's Life Insurance and Annuity Consumer Guide states that any change in personal circumstances since a policy was first purchased may require a different strategy. A thorough evaluation may indicate that replacing or changing a policy is advisable — but the CDI also identifies specific cautions that apply before any such change is made.
A review typically looks at the policy's current death benefit, its cash value (the amount available if the policy were surrendered), any outstanding loans against the policy, and whether the policy is on track to remain in force. It also looks at whether the policyholder's beneficiary designations and ownership structure still reflect their intentions.
The CDI guide treats this kind of check-in as an ordinary part of owning insurance. It notes that because needs and financial situations change over time, it is important to understand and review insurance policies to decide whether the same policies are still right. The factors the guide lists for choosing a coverage amount in the first place are the same factors a review revisits: marital status, the number of dependents and the cost of their support, future education needs, current and anticipated family income, and current assets and debt obligations.
Your Annual Policy Report: What California Law Requires
California law gives policyholders a baseline document for any review: the annual policy report. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959 requires insurers to provide each policyholder with an annual report on the status of the policy, for policies designated for illustrations.
For universal life policies the annual report must include:
- The beginning and end date of the current report period
- The policy value at the start and end of the period
- All amounts credited or debited during the period, identified by type, including interest, mortality charges, expense charges, and rider charges
- The current death benefit at the end of the period
- The net cash surrender value at the end of the period
- The amount of any outstanding loans
For fixed premium universal life policies, the report must also include a notice if — using the policy's minimum contractual interest, mortality, and expense loads with continued scheduled premium payments — the net cash surrender value would not maintain insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period.
For flexible premium universal life policies, the report must include a notice if — using the policy's minimum contractual interest, mortality, and expense loads — the net cash surrender value will not maintain insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period unless further premium payments are made.
For all other covered policies, the annual report must include, where applicable: the current death benefit, the annual contract premium, the current cash surrender value, the current dividend, how that dividend is being applied, and the outstanding loan amount.
The statute goes beyond this list of figures. If the annual report does not include an in-force illustration, it must prominently display a notice explaining that the policy owner may request a current illustration annually without charge, and that the policy owner should contact the state insurance department if the illustration does not arrive within thirty days of the request. The same notice states that replacement or changes in coverage should not be considered without first requesting a current illustration. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959)
If the insurer has made an adverse change in nonguaranteed elements that could affect the policy since the last annual report, the report must prominently display a notice of that fact and the nature of the change. For policies that do not build nonforfeiture values, the insurer must send an annual report only for years in which it has changed nonguaranteed policy elements. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959)
Key Items to Examine During a Policy Review
The annual report required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959 is the natural starting point for a review. Several items in that report deserve close attention.
Cash surrender value. This figure tells you what the policy is worth today if it were ended. It is relevant whether you are considering keeping the policy, exchanging it, or simply understanding what you hold. You can read more about how cash value accumulates and is calculated.
Outstanding loan balance. If you have borrowed against the policy, the annual report will show the outstanding amount. The mechanics of policy loans are worth understanding before drawing any conclusions.
Death benefit and loans together. The CDI guide's glossary explains that the amount paid to the beneficiary will be reduced by any unpaid policy loans and interest on those loans. For that reason, the current death benefit and the outstanding loan balance in the annual report are most useful when read side by side.
Policy value and charges. For universal life policies, the report shows the policy value at the end of the previous period and at the end of the current period, along with the amounts credited or debited by type. The CDI guide explains that universal life cash values accumulate by crediting premium payments and interest to a fund from which deductions are made for expenses and cost of insurance, and that predictions of future costs depend heavily on the accuracy of interest rate projections. Comparing the two policy values against the listed credits and charges shows how the fund moved during the year.
Lapse-warning notice. For universal life policies, Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959 requires the insurer to include a specific notice in the annual report if the policy is at risk of lapsing — that is, terminating for insufficient value. If your report contains such a notice, that is a signal to examine policy lapse risk more closely.
Changes in personal circumstances. The CDI guide notes that any change in circumstances since the policy was first purchased may require a different strategy. A review is an opportunity to consider whether the coverage amount, the beneficiary designations, and the policy structure still match your situation. Reviewing beneficiary designations and policy ownership are often part of this process.
Cautions Before Making Changes to an Existing Policy
The CDI's consumer guide identifies several cautions that apply when a policyholder is considering replacing or changing a policy. These are not reasons to avoid a review — they are reasons to conduct one carefully.
Start-up costs. A new policy may carry costs in its early years that the existing policy no longer has.
The contestable period. A new policy may require waiting one or two years before it passes through the contestable period. During that period, the insurer may cancel the policy or refuse to pay a claim based on omissions or misstatements in the application.
Age and premium. Because the policyholder is older than when the original policy was purchased, a new policy may carry a higher premium.
Tax consequences. The CDI guide states that there may be specific tax consequences when replacing or changing a current policy. A tax professional addresses the specifics of any individual situation.
Using cash value to fund a new policy. If the cash value of an existing policy is used to pay premiums on a new policy, those values may not be sufficient to support the new policy in future years.
Amendment or conversion within the same company. The CDI guide notes that a policyholder may have the ability to amend or convert the current policy to a newer product within the same company without loss of rights or accumulated cash value. The guide states that it may be in your best interest to contact your current agent or company and to inform them of your intent. The mechanics of converting a policy within the same company are a separate topic worth understanding.
Illustrations used for comparison. The CDI guide states that illustrations should never be the only factor used in deciding to replace or change a policy, and that illustrations presented for comparison purposes may not give a complete picture of the new policy's future. The guide recommends obtaining a second opinion as well as consulting the current agent.
California's Replacement Notice Requirement
When a replacement — buying a new life insurance policy or annuity and discontinuing or changing an existing one — is being considered, California law establishes a specific procedural requirement.
Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.4 requires the agent to present a "Notice Regarding Replacement of Life Insurance" to the applicant no later than at the time of taking the application. The notice must be signed by both the applicant and the agent, and left with the applicant. The agent must also obtain a list of all existing policies to be replaced, identified by insurer name, insured, and contract number.
The applicant must sign a statement indicating whether replacement is involved in the transaction. The agent must also submit a signed statement as to whether the agent knows replacement is or may be involved. Where replacement is involved, the agent must leave with the applicant the original or a copy of all printed communications used in the presentation, and must submit a copy of the replacement notice to the replacing insurer with the application. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.4)
The text of the notice required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.4 states: "You will not know for sure unless you make a careful comparison of your existing benefits and the proposed benefits" and "Hear both sides before you decide."
The notice also tells the applicant to ask the company or agent that sold the existing policy for information about it, and it states that the existing company must be notified that its policy may be replaced. (Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.4)
If you are presented with a replacement notice, that document is a prompt to examine the comparison carefully — not a signal to proceed or to decline. The topic of replacing a life insurance policy involves additional considerations covered separately.
How to Request a Policy Review
A policyholder in this position typically begins by gathering documents. The most important is the most recent annual policy report, which Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959 establishes as the baseline record of the policy's current status. The original policy contract and any rider documents are also useful.
The CDI consumer guide states that it may be in your best interest to contact your current agent or company and to inform them of your intent.
An in-force illustration — a projection of how the policy is expected to perform under current assumptions — is another document that can be requested from the insurer and is often part of a thorough review. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959, the insurer must furnish an in-force illustration of current and future benefits and values, based on its present illustrated scale, when the policy owner requests one, and no signature or other acknowledgment of receipt may be required.