California's Insurance Code gives policyowners specific rights to performance information every year, including the right to request a free in-force illustration at any time. Understanding those rights is the first step toward evaluating what your policy is actually doing.
Permanent life insurance—whole life, universal life, and similar products—combines a death benefit with a cash-value accumulation feature. Premiums paid in excess of the cost of the death benefit accumulate with interest inside the policy, according to the California Department of Insurance (CDI) Life Insurance Guide. That accumulation is what most people mean when they ask how a policy is "performing."
Inside any permanent policy, some elements are contract-fixed and some are variable (subject to change). Contract-fixed elements—such as a minimum death benefit or a minimum interest crediting rate—are fixed by the contract and cannot be reduced. Variable elements—such as credited interest rates, dividends, and mortality charges (the cost the insurer deducts for providing the death benefit)—are subject to change by the insurer and are not fixed by contract, as stated in Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956(a)(12).
California law requires that contract-fixed elements be shown before corresponding variable elements in any illustration and be clearly labeled as contract-fixed, per Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956(a)(8). Variable elements must be clearly labeled as subject to change. Actual results may be more or less favorable than any illustrated values, per Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956(b)(5).
Understanding this distinction—contract-fixed versus variable—is the foundation for reading everything else your insurer sends you. For a closer look at how cash value accumulates inside a policy, that topic is covered separately on this site.
What California Law Requires Your Insurer to Send You Each Year
California law requires insurers to provide each policyowner with an annual report on the status of the policy, under Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a). The required contents differ depending on the type of policy.
For universal life policies, the annual report must include: the beginning and end dates of the report period; the policy value at the start and end of that period; the total amounts credited or debited to the policy value, itemized by type—interest, mortality charges, expense charges, and riders; the current death benefit; the net cash surrender value (the amount available if you surrendered the policy after deducting any applicable charges and loans); and the outstanding loan balance, if any. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1).
The law also requires specific lapse-warning notices. For fixed-premium universal life policies, if the net cash surrender value would not maintain insurance in force through the next reporting period under contract-minimum assumptions, the report must include a notice to that effect. For flexible-premium universal life policies, a similar notice is required if the policy would not stay in force without additional premium payments. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(G)–(H).
For other permanent policies such as whole life, the annual report must include, where applicable: the current death benefit; the annual contract premium; the current cash surrender value; the current dividend (a return of a portion of premium that some policies pay); how that dividend is being applied; and the outstanding loan amount. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(2).
If the insurer has made an adverse change to variable elements since the last annual report, that fact and the nature of the change must be prominently disclosed in the report. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(d).
Your Right to Request a Free In-Force Illustration
An in-force illustration is a projection of your policy's future benefits and values based on the insurer's current assumptions. It is more detailed than the annual report and shows how the policy is expected to behave going forward.
If your annual report does not include an in-force illustration, it must prominently display an IMPORTANT POLICY OWNER NOTICE advising you that you may request one annually, without charge, by calling or writing the insurer or contacting your agent. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(b). If you do not receive the illustration within 30 days of your request, the notice directs you to contact your state insurance department—the California Department of Insurance.
Upon request, the insurer must furnish an in-force illustration of current and future benefits and values based on its present illustrated scale. No signature or acknowledgment of receipt is required to receive it. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(c). The illustration must comply with the content and format requirements of Cal. Ins. Code §§ 10509.955 and 10509.956, including the requirement that any illustration of variable elements be accompanied by a statement that benefits and values are not fixed by contract, assumptions are subject to change, and actual results may be more or less favorable.
A separate page on this site covers in-force illustrations in greater detail, including how to read the columns and what the three projection bases mean.
How the Original Illustration Serves as Your Comparison Baseline
When you applied for your policy, a basic illustration was likely used in the sale. If so, a signed copy was required to be submitted to the insurer and provided to you at the time of application, per Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.958(a)(1). If the policy was issued differently from how it was applied for, a revised illustration labeled "Revised Illustration" was required to be sent with the policy. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.958(a)(2).
That original or revised illustration is your starting reference point. It showed contract-fixed and variable values at policy years 5, 10, and 20, and at age 70 if applicable, on three bases: the policy's contractual minimums alone; the insurer's illustrated scale at the time of sale; and the illustrated scale with variable elements reduced. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956(c)(1).
The illustration also included a statement that currently illustrated variable elements are assumed to continue unchanged, but that this is not likely to occur. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956(b)(5). Comparing your current annual report or a new in-force illustration against that original document can show how actual performance has tracked against the assumptions made at the time of sale.
Key Items to Look for When Reviewing Your Annual Report
When you receive your annual report, a few specific items are worth examining carefully.
Policy value movement. Compare the policy value at the end of the current period to the prior period. The itemized credits and debits—interest credited, mortality charges deducted, expense charges, and rider costs—explain what drove the change. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(B)–(C).
Net cash surrender value and outstanding loans. The net cash surrender value is the amount you would receive if you surrendered the policy today, after deducting any applicable charges and loans. Outstanding loans are deducted from policy proceeds at death or at surrender, according to the CDI Life Insurance Guide. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(E)–(F).
Lapse-warning notices. If the report includes a notice that the net cash surrender value may not maintain insurance in force through the next reporting period, that is a disclosure required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(G)–(H). It is not a cancellation notice, but it does indicate that the policy's funding may need attention. The topic of policy lapse is covered separately on this site.
Adverse-change notices. Look for any disclosure that the insurer has changed variable elements since the last report. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(d). A change to mortality charges or credited interest rates can affect how long the policy remains in force at the current premium level.
In-force illustration or the IMPORTANT POLICY OWNER NOTICE. If neither is present, contact your insurer or agent. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(b).
Tax considerations. The CDI Life Insurance Guide notes that a policy lapse or surrender may create a taxable event and may generate a Form 1099. A tax advisor addresses the specific tax consequences for your situation.
If the annual report raises questions about whether the policy is on track, that is often the point at which policyowners consider requesting a formal policy review or asking for an updated in-force illustration. An underperforming policy may present additional decisions that are worth understanding before taking any action.
What to Do If You Have Questions About Your Policy's Performance
The most direct first step is to request a free in-force illustration from your insurer. Policyowners may do this annually by phone, mail, or through their agent, at no charge. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(b)–(c). The illustration will show how the policy is projected to perform going forward under current assumptions.
If you do not receive the illustration within 30 days of your request, contact the California Department of Insurance. The required IMPORTANT POLICY OWNER NOTICE in Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(b) directs policyowners to take that step.
The CDI Life Insurance Guide advises obtaining cash value information based on the policy's contract-minimum value and consulting a tax advisor before any lapse or surrender. Those two steps—getting the contract-minimum-basis numbers and understanding the tax picture—give a policyowner a clearer foundation for any further decisions. For questions about policy loans against the cash value, that topic is covered separately on this site.