California law gives policyowners specific tools to evaluate this situation: a required annual report with defined contents, a comparison baseline in the illustration signed at the time of sale, and a set of cautions from the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to consider before making any change to an existing policy.
What Does It Mean for a Permanent Life Insurance Policy to Underperform?
Underperformance means the policy's actual values—its cash value, its death benefit sustainability, or both—are tracking below what the original illustration projected.
The illustration signed at the time of sale is the baseline for that comparison. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.958, if a basic illustration is used in the sale and the policy is applied for as illustrated, a copy of that illustration must be submitted to the insurer at the time of the policy application, and a copy also shall be provided to the applicant.
Common Reasons Permanent Policies Fall Short of Projections
For universal life policies, Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(C) requires the annual report to itemize the amounts credited or debited to the policy value by type—including interest, mortality charges, expenses, and rider costs.
Your Annual Policy Report: What California Law Requires Insurers to Send You
California law gives policyowners a right to specific information each year. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959, insurers must provide an annual report for policies designated for illustrations.
For universal life policies, that report must include:
- The beginning and end dates of the current report period
- The policy value at the start and end of the period
- The total amounts credited or debited to the policy value during the period, identified by type—interest, mortality, expenses, and riders
- The current death benefit at the end of the period
- The net cash surrender value at the end of the period
- The amount of any outstanding loans
For fixed premium universal life policies, the statute adds a specific notice requirement: if, under the assumptions set out in § 10509.959(a)(1)(G), including continued scheduled premium payments, the policy's net cash surrender value is such that it would not maintain insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period, a notice to this effect shall be included in the report.
For flexible premium universal life policies, a parallel notice is required: if, under the assumptions set out in § 10509.959(a)(1)(H), the policy's net cash surrender value will not maintain insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period unless further premium payments are made, a notice to this effect shall be included in the report.
For other policy types, the annual report must include, where applicable: the current death benefit, the annual contract premium, the current cash surrender value, the current dividend, how that dividend is being applied, and the outstanding loan amount.
Locating and reading your most recent annual report is a practical starting point when evaluating policy performance.
Reading the Warning Notice in Your Annual Report
The lapse-warning notice required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959(a)(1)(G) and (H) is a notice that, under the assumptions set out there, the policy's net cash surrender value would not maintain insurance in force until the end of the next reporting period (for flexible premium policies, unless further premium payments are made).
The Illustration You Received at Sale: Why It Matters Now
The illustration provided at the time of sale is more than a sales document. Under Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.958, it is the signed projection baseline for the policy as purchased.
If the policy was issued other than as applied for, a revised illustration labeled "Revised Illustration" must have accompanied the policy. That revised illustration, rather than the original, becomes the applicable baseline.
Locating the original or revised illustration allows a direct comparison: what was projected at sale versus what the annual report now shows. That comparison is the foundation of any meaningful evaluation of whether and how the policy has underperformed.
What a Thorough Policy Evaluation Looks At
The CDI consumer guide states that financial needs should be thoroughly evaluated before changes are made to existing policies.
The CDI guide also notes that any change in your personal circumstances since you first purchased life insurance may require a different strategy.
A policy review brings these elements together in a structured way. It draws on the annual report, the original or revised illustration, and an in-force illustration to give a policyowner a more complete picture of where the policy stands and what options exist.
Cautions the California Department of Insurance Raises Before Any Policy Change
The CDI consumer guide lists specific cautions for policyowners who are considering replacing or changing a life insurance policy. These are risks to be aware of, not a recommendation for or against any particular course of action.
Start-up costs and the contestable period. A policyowner may have to pay “start up” costs again and may be required to wait one or two years before a new policy passes through the contestable period. During the contestable period the insurer is contractually entitled to cancel the policy or refuse to pay a claim based on omissions, or mistaken or untrue statements in the application.
Higher premiums due to age. The CDI guide notes that a policyowner may pay a higher premium for new insurance over the duration of the policy because they are older than when they first purchased life insurance.
Cash value used to fund a new policy may fall short. If the cash value from an existing policy is used to pay premiums on a new policy, the CDI guide notes that those values may not be sufficient to support the new policy in future years. That could require additional premium payments to keep the new policy in force.
Tax consequences. The CDI guide notes that there may be specific tax consequences when replacing or changing a policy. It does not specify outcomes.
Amending or converting within the same insurer. The CDI guide specifically notes that a policyowner may have the ability to amend or convert a current policy to a newer product within the same insurance company without any loss of rights or accumulated cash value. It adds that it may be in your best interest to contact your current agent or company and to inform them of your intent.
The CDI's consistent message is to evaluate thoroughly before any change.
Questions to Bring to a Policy Review
A structured policy review is more productive when a policyowner arrives with specific questions. The following are grounded in the statutory disclosures and CDI guidance described on this page.
Has the insurer sent an annual report as required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959? If so, does it include a lapse-warning notice, and which type—fixed premium or flexible premium?
Where is the original or revised illustration from the time of sale? How do the values shown in the most recent annual report compare to what was projected at that time?
Have personal circumstances changed since the policy was purchased? The CDI guide identifies this as a relevant factor in evaluating whether the current policy still fits the policyowner's needs.
Are there amendment or conversion options within the current insurer? The CDI guide notes these may preserve accumulated cash value and rights without loss. Understanding what options exist within the current policy is part of a complete evaluation.
Have any policy loans affected the policy's performance? For universal life policies, the annual report must show the amount of outstanding policy loans, if any, as of the end of the current report period.
How a Policy Review Can Help Clarify Next Steps
A policy review is a structured examination of the current policy's values, projections, and available options. Its purpose is to give a policyowner a clearer picture of where the policy stands.
The review draws on three main documents: the annual report required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.959, the original or revised illustration required by Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.958, and an in-force illustration that projects the policy's trajectory from today. Together, those documents show the gap between original expectations and current reality, and what the policy may look like under different assumptions going forward.
The review provides the information a policyowner needs to have an informed conversation about the options.