A review of an existing annuity contract is not a decision to keep or replace it. It is an opportunity to understand what the contract actually says, what California law requires of the people who sold it to you, and what questions are worth asking before you take any action.
What an Annuity Review Covers
An annuity is a contract between you and an insurance company. You make one or more premium payments, and the insurance company agrees to make income payments to you, either for life or for a specified term. The California Department of Insurance (CDI) describes annuities as complex, with commissions and other fees that affect the overall value of the contract.
Because annuities are long-term contracts, the CDI notes that the decision to buy one — or to change one — should be made carefully. A periodic review is an opportunity to confirm that the contract still aligns with your financial situation, age, health, and goals. It is not a conclusion about what to do next. That conclusion depends on facts specific to you, and a licensed producer works through those facts with you.
Annuities come in several forms. If you want background on how different contract types are structured before reviewing your own, the annuities overview page covers the general landscape.
Key Contract Terms to Locate Before Your Review
Before any conversation about an existing annuity, it helps to know where to find the contract's cost and timing provisions. The most important of these is the surrender charge schedule.
A surrender charge is a fee the insurance company deducts if you withdraw money or cancel the contract before a specified period ends. Many contracts also impose partial-surrender charges or excess-withdrawal charges — fees triggered when you take out more than a permitted amount in a given year. These charges reduce the amount you actually receive.
California law addresses how these charges must be disclosed. For annuity contracts issued to senior citizens, California Insurance Code section 10127.13 requires that the contract contain a notice disclosing the location of all surrender charges, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information. That notice must appear in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page of the contract.
Knowing where that notice appears — and reading it carefully — is a practical first step before any review conversation. The CDI reminds consumers that an annuity is a long-term investment, and tying up money for many years is a key consideration.
California Suitability Factors Relevant to an Existing Annuity
When a licensed producer recommends an annuity transaction — whether a purchase, an exchange, or a replacement — California law specifies the information the producer must consider. Understanding these categories helps an annuity owner recognize what a thorough review should cover.
A "recommendation," under California Insurance Code section 10509.913(g), means advice or guidance that results in a purchase, exchange, or replacement of an annuity. "Suitability information," under section 10509.913(i), is the information reasonably appropriate to determine whether a recommendation is suitable. The statute lists fourteen categories:
- Age
- Annual income
- Financial situation and needs, including the financial resources used to fund the annuity
- Financial experience
- Financial objectives
- Intended use of the annuity
- Financial time horizon
- Existing assets, including investment and life insurance holdings
- Liquidity needs
- Liquid net worth (the value of assets that can be converted to cash quickly)
- Risk tolerance
- Tax status
- Whether the consumer has a reverse mortgage
- Whether the consumer intends to apply for means-tested government benefits, including Medi-Cal or the veterans' aid and attendance benefit
These categories are what California law requires a producer to consider before making a recommendation. They are not a checklist for reaching your own conclusion. They are a framework for understanding what a licensed producer is obligated to work through with you.
If you hold a fixed annuity or a multi-year fixed-rate annuity, the same suitability framework applies when any change to that contract is recommended.
What California Law Defines as a Replacement
If a review leads to a conversation about moving money from one annuity contract to another, it is important to understand when that transaction becomes a "replacement" under California law. Replacement triggers specific regulatory requirements for the producer and insurer involved.
California Insurance Code section 10509.913(h) defines replacement as a transaction in which a new policy or contract is to be purchased, and the existing contract has been or is to be:
- Lapsed, forfeited, surrendered, partially surrendered, assigned to the replacing insurer, or otherwise terminated
- Converted to reduced paid-up insurance, continued as extended term insurance, or otherwise reduced in value through nonforfeiture benefits or other policy values
- Amended to reduce benefits or shorten the term for which coverage remains in force
- Reissued with any reduction in cash value
- Used in a financed purchase (meaning the existing contract's value is used to fund the new one)
The statute places responsibility on the proposing producer or insurer to recognize when a transaction constitutes a replacement. That recognition is not optional — the law states the producer or insurer is responsible for making that determination regardless of whether a producer is involved.
Understanding this definition helps an annuity owner ask the right questions if a change is proposed. For a broader look at how existing contracts are evaluated, the existing policy review page covers the general review framework across life insurance and annuity contracts.
Protections California Law Provides to Senior Annuity Owners
California law provides specific protections to annuity owners who are 65 or older. These protections exist alongside any other duties the insurer or producer may have.
Duty of honesty, good faith, and fair dealing. California Insurance Code section 785 states that all insurers, brokers, agents, and others engaged in the transaction of insurance owe a prospective insured who is 65 years of age or older a duty of honesty, good faith, and fair dealing. The statute specifies that this duty is in addition to any other duty, whether express or implied, that may exist.
Written disclosure when assets are liquidated to fund a purchase. California Insurance Code section 789.8(b) requires that if a life agent offers to sell an elder any life insurance or annuity product, the agent must advise the elder in writing that selling or liquidating any stock, bond, IRA, certificate of deposit, mutual fund, annuity, or other asset to fund the purchase may have tax consequences, early withdrawal penalties, or other costs or penalties. The written notice must also state that the elder may wish to consult independent legal or financial advice before selling or liquidating any assets and before purchasing the product being offered. Tax and legal questions that arise from this disclosure are addressed by a tax or legal professional, not by an insurance producer.
The right not to be pressured. The CDI states plainly that an agent should not push a consumer to buy an annuity — that is illegal — and that the law requires honest and accurate information on the terms, rules, costs, and benefits of any annuity offered.
If you feel pressured about an annuity, you can contact the California Department of Insurance at 1-800-927-4357 or at insurance.ca.gov.
Questions to Ask When Reviewing Your Annuity
The CDI offers a set of questions to help consumers think through whether an annuity fits their situation. These questions are not a formula for a decision. They are a starting point for a conversation with a licensed producer or a trusted financial advisor.
The CDI asks:
- Can I afford to tie up my money for many years?
- Will I have enough money left to have an emergency fund, such as a bank account?
- Will I have enough money left for long-term care and other health care needs?
- Can I cover my expenses until income payments begin?
The CDI notes that the answer to whether an annuity remains appropriate depends on financial situation, age, health, and goals. The CDI also states clearly: "We do not recommend or disapprove of annuities. We want to give you the information to make the best decision for you."
These questions apply equally when reviewing a contract you already hold. A review is not only for prospective buyers. An owner whose circumstances have changed — in income, health, liquidity needs, or time horizon — has the same reason to revisit these questions as someone considering a first purchase.