A deferred annuity is a long-term insurance contract with two distinct periods: an accumulation period when money grows, and a payout period when income payments begin. The main reason to buy one is to allow money to grow tax-deferred for a period before income starts. California law and federal tax rules both shape how these contracts behave.
What Is a Deferred Annuity?
A deferred annuity is a contract between a buyer and an insurance company. The buyer pays premiums—either as a single lump sum or as a series of payments over time. The money paid is also called principal. In return, the insurer agrees to pay income at a future date, typically at retirement.
The California Department of Insurance (CDI) describes two broad timing types. An immediate annuity begins income payments within a year of purchase. The main reason to buy an immediate annuity is to receive a regular income right away in retirement. A deferred annuity delays income payments until many years later. The main reason to buy a deferred annuity is to have money grow tax-deferred for a period before income begins.
The deferred structure has two distinct periods. The first is the accumulation period, when premiums are paid and money grows inside the contract. The second is the amortization period (also called the payout period), when the insurer makes income payments to the annuitant—the person whose life the payments are based on.
Understanding which period a contract is currently in, and how long each period lasts, is one of the first things to clarify when reviewing any deferred annuity. The annuities overview on this site provides broader context on how annuities fit into retirement planning.
The Two Phases: Accumulation and Payout
The Accumulation Period
The accumulation period is when money grows inside the contract. According to the CDI consumer guide, this period can last for over ten years. During this time, the owner generally cannot take money out freely. The CDI guide states that no money can typically be taken out in the first year. After that, some contracts allow limited withdrawals without a penalty; larger withdrawals usually trigger a surrender charge.
During the accumulation period, earnings inside the contract grow tax-deferred under federal law. Internal Revenue Code § 72 governs the federal tax treatment of annuity contracts. Tax deferral means the owner does not pay income tax on earnings as they accumulate inside the contract—tax is deferred until money is actually withdrawn or payments begin.
The Payout (Amortization) Period
The amortization period is when the insurer begins making income payments. According to the CDI guide, this period can last as long as the annuitant's life, and even the life of a beneficiary. The length and structure of payments depend on the payout option chosen in the contract.
Under IRC § 72(e)(2)(A), amounts received on or after the annuity starting date are included in gross income. The annuity starting date is the date on which the payout period begins. Before that date, different tax rules apply, as described in the tax section below.
The transition from accumulation to payout is a significant decision point. A policyowner approaching that transition may want to review the contract terms carefully before making any elections. The existing annuity review page on this site describes what that kind of review typically covers.
Fixed, Variable, and Indexed: How Deferred Annuities Earn Interest
Deferred annuities differ in how they credit interest during the accumulation period. The CDI consumer guide describes three main types.
Fixed Annuities
A fixed annuity earns interest at rates set by the insurance company, or in another way described in the annuity contract. The interest rate may be set for only one year or for up to ten years. The CDI guide flags two things to watch for with fixed annuities.
First, watch for fixed annuities with a minimum contractual interest rate of 0%. The owner will not lose principal, but money will not grow. Second, watch for teaser rates: some annuities offer a higher contractual interest rate for the first year only, then the rate drops. The CDI guide advises asking what the minimum rate is and how long the higher rate lasts. The guide also cautions against ads showing high interest rates that are not contractually assured—if a rate is not contractually assured, it cannot be counted on.
Fixed annuities are covered in more detail on a dedicated page within this site.
Variable Annuities
A variable annuity works differently. The insurance company invests the annuity in stocks, bonds, or other investments, based on the level of risk the owner chooses. If the fund does not perform well, the owner may lose some or all of the investment. Variable annuities carry investment risk that fixed annuities do not. The CDI guide directs readers to the SEC's resource on variable annuities for additional information.
Equity-Indexed (Fixed Indexed) Annuities
An equity-indexed annuity—also called a fixed indexed annuity—has an interest rate that is usually based on a stock market index. The owner has a contractually stated minimum interest rate. The CDI guide notes that the minimums are conservative and the interest might be higher, but the insurance company decides how much above the minimum the owner receives.
Fixed indexed annuities are covered separately on this site.
Surrender Charges: What They Are and Why They Matter
A surrender charge is a penalty the insurer may impose if the owner withdraws money during the accumulation period. The CDI consumer guide is direct on this point: surrender charges can be high, and the owner may end up with less money than originally invested.
The CDI guide describes the general pattern: no money can typically be taken out in the first contract year. After that, some money may be withdrawable without a penalty, depending on the contract terms. Withdrawals beyond that amount typically trigger surrender charges.
Surrender charges matter for two reasons beyond the owner's own access to funds. First, if a beneficiary may need to cash in the annuity after the owner's death—before income payments have started—the beneficiary may owe a surrender charge. The CDI guide advises asking the agent whether the beneficiary would have to pay a surrender charge in that situation.
Second, California law imposes a specific disclosure requirement for senior citizens. Under California Insurance Code § 10127.13, all individual annuity contracts for senior citizens that contain a charge upon surrender, partial surrender, excess withdrawal, or penalties upon surrender must include a notice disclosing the location of all of the following: the charge, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information. That notice must be in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page of the policy.
This requirement means a senior citizen reviewing a deferred annuity contract should be able to find surrender charge information prominently disclosed at the front of the document. If that notice is absent from a contract that contains surrender charges, that is worth raising with the CDI.
Tax Deferral and Federal Tax Treatment
Tax deferral is the central financial feature of a deferred annuity during the accumulation period. Earnings inside the contract are not taxed as they accumulate. Tax is deferred until money comes out.
Federal tax treatment of deferred annuity withdrawals is governed by IRC § 72(e). The rules differ depending on whether a withdrawal occurs before or after the annuity starting date.
Withdrawals Before the Annuity Starting Date
Under IRC § 72(e)(2)(B), amounts received before the annuity starting date are included in gross income to the extent they are allocable to income on the contract—that is, to the earnings that have accumulated inside the contract. Amounts allocable to the investment in the contract (the owner's own premiums, also called basis) are not included in gross income. In plain terms: when money comes out before the payout period begins, earnings come out first and are taxed; a return of the owner's own premiums is generally not taxed.
Loans and Assignments
Under IRC § 72(e)(4)(A), if an individual receives any amount as a loan under the contract, or assigns or pledges any portion of the contract's value, that amount or portion is treated as a distribution received under the contract. This means loans against a deferred annuity contract, and pledges of the contract's value as collateral, may trigger income inclusion under the same rules that apply to withdrawals.
Transfers Without Full Consideration
Under IRC § 72(e)(4)(C), if an individual transfers an annuity contract without full and adequate consideration, that individual is treated as receiving an amount equal to the excess of the contract's cash surrender value over the investment in the contract. There is an exception for certain transfers between spouses or transfers incident to divorce, as provided under federal tax law.
Aggregation of Contracts
Under IRC § 72(e)(12), all annuity contracts issued by the same company to the same policyholder during any calendar year are treated as one annuity contract for purposes of calculating amounts includible in gross income. This anti-abuse rule can affect how taxable amounts are calculated when a person holds multiple annuity contracts from the same insurer.
This is general federal tax information. The tax consequences of any specific annuity contract depend on the individual's circumstances, the contract terms, and applicable law. A qualified tax professional addresses questions about a specific situation.
California Consumer Protections for Seniors
California law includes a specific protection for senior citizens who hold individual annuity contracts with surrender charges.
California Insurance Code § 10127.13 requires that all individual annuity contracts for senior citizens containing a charge upon surrender, partial surrender, excess withdrawal, or penalties upon surrender include a notice disclosing the location of the charge, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information. The notice must be in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page of the policy.
The statute also specifies that a policy shall have just one cover page. If both the surrender charge notice and the statutorily required right-to-examine notice appear on the cover page, they must appear on the same page.
This requirement became operative on July 1, 2015, and was amended effective January 1, 2016.
The CDI publishes a consumer guide titled Annuities: What Seniors Need to Know, available at insurance.ca.gov. That guide covers the types of annuities, surrender charge warnings, teaser rate warnings, and the CDI's consumer tip about liquidity during the accumulation period.
Consumers with questions or complaints about an annuity contract can contact the California Department of Insurance at 800-927-4357 or visit the CDI website at insurance.ca.gov.
If you are already holding a deferred annuity and want to understand how these protections apply to your contract, a policy review is a reasonable starting point. You can reach LifeInsuranceAdvisor.co at (888) 601-3119 to discuss what a review covers.
Key Questions to Ask Before Buying a Deferred Annuity
The CDI consumer guide and the federal tax rules together point to a set of questions worth working through before purchasing a deferred annuity. These are not a substitute for reviewing the actual contract or consulting a licensed professional, but they frame the decision clearly.
Will I need access to this money during the accumulation period? The CDI guidance states that consumers who anticipate needing access to funds during the accumulation period may find a deferred annuity unsuitable, given that surrender charges can reduce amounts received below original principal and no withdrawals are typically permitted in the first year.
What is the minimum contractual interest rate, and how long does any higher introductory rate last? Some contracts offer a teaser rate—a higher rate for the first year only—that drops afterward. The CDI guide advises asking what the minimum rate is and how long the higher rate lasts. A minimum contractual rate of 0% means money will not grow, even though principal is not lost.
What are the surrender charges, how long do they last, and would a beneficiary owe them? Surrender charges vary by contract. Understanding the charge schedule—including whether it applies to a beneficiary who cashes in the contract after the owner's death—is important before signing.
Is the interest rate contractually assured, or is it a rate shown in an advertisement? The CDI guide cautions against ads showing high interest rates that are not contractually assured. If a rate is not contractually assured, it cannot be counted on.
For variable annuities: what is the investment risk, and could principal be lost? Variable annuities invest in stocks, bonds, or other investments. If the fund does not perform well, the owner may lose some or all of the investment. This is a materially different risk profile from a fixed or fixed indexed annuity.
These questions apply whether a person is considering a new purchase or reviewing a contract already in force. The annuity income options page on this site covers how payout structures work once the accumulation period ends.