The core principle: annuity growth is not taxed while it accumulates inside a deferred contract. When money comes out, the taxable portion depends on whether you have an "investment in the contract" — that is, after-tax dollars you contributed — and on whether you are receiving periodic annuity payments or taking an early withdrawal.
The tax rules described on this page are federal rules drawn from the Internal Revenue Code and IRS guidance. This page does not address California income-tax conformity; a tax attorney or tax accountant can advise on how California treats annuity income in your specific situation.
Why Annuity Taxation Starts With One Question: Did You Use Pre-Tax or After-Tax Money?
The answer to that question determines whether your annuity payments are fully or partially taxable.
The IRS explains that pension or annuity payments are fully taxable when the owner has no investment in the contract — meaning no after-tax contributions were made, the employer did not withhold after-tax amounts, or all after-tax contributions were already received tax-free in prior years. When after-tax dollars were used to fund the contract, payments are partially taxable.
The California Department of Insurance (CDI) states this plainly in its consumer guide: "You pay taxes on the whole income payment if you bought the annuity using pre-tax dollars. You only pay taxes on the interest if you bought the annuity using after-tax dollars."
This distinction maps closely to the difference between qualified and nonqualified annuities. A qualified annuity funded with pre-tax retirement dollars typically produces fully taxable payments. A nonqualified annuity funded with after-tax dollars typically produces partially taxable payments, because a portion of each payment is a return of money you already paid tax on.
Tax Deferral During the Accumulation Phase
One of the defining features of a deferred annuity is that growth inside the contract is not taxed as it accumulates. The CDI states: "You do not have to pay taxes until you get income payments."
This deferral has practical implications for how the product is used. The CDI notes that "to get the tax benefit, letting the deferred annuity grow as a long-term investment is the common practice." Taking money out early can reduce or eliminate that benefit and may trigger additional taxes, as described below.
Two related points from the CDI are worth noting. First, "the government does not set an age when an owner is required to start taking income payments from an annuity outside of an IRA or 401(k) plan. However, your annuity contract may specify an age." Second, "it usually does not make sense to put your annuity into an IRA, because the annuity already gives you tax deferral." Adding an annuity inside a tax-deferred retirement account does not add a second layer of tax deferral.
How the Exclusion Ratio Works Once Payments Begin
When a nonqualified annuity owner begins receiving regular income payments — a process called annuitization — each payment is divided into a taxable portion and a tax-free portion. The formula that determines this split is called the exclusion ratio.
Under IRC § 72(b)(1), gross income does not include the part of an annuity payment that bears the same ratio to the total payment as the investment in the contract (the owner's after-tax contributions, as of the annuity starting date) bears to the expected return under the contract (the total amount the owner is projected to receive). In plain terms: if your after-tax investment represents a certain fraction of what you expect to receive over the life of the contract, that same fraction of each payment is excluded from income.
IRC § 72(b)(2) limits this exclusion: the excluded portion of any payment cannot exceed the unrecovered investment in the contract immediately before that payment. Once the full investment has been returned tax-free, IRC § 72(b)(4) provides that all subsequent payments are fully included in gross income.
IRS Topic 410 explains that taxpayers figure the tax on partly taxable payments using either the general rule or the simplified method. For annuity starting dates after November 18, 1996, the simplified method is generally required. IRS Topic 411 covers the mechanics of both methods in detail.
One important point from the CDI: "Income payments are taxed as regular income, not as capital gains." The favorable capital-gains rates that apply to stock sales do not apply to annuity income.
What Happens When You Take a Withdrawal Before Annuitization
A withdrawal taken before the annuity starting date — the date regular income payments begin — is treated differently from a periodic annuity payment. For nonqualified contracts entered into after August 13, 1982, IRC § 72(e) applies an earnings-first rule.
Under IRC § 72(e)(2)(B), an amount received before the annuity starting date is included in gross income to the extent it is allocable to income on the contract, and excluded to the extent it is allocable to the investment in the contract. IRC § 72(e)(3)(A) defines what is allocable to income: an amount is treated as income to the extent it does not exceed the excess of the contract's cash value (determined without regard to any surrender charge) over the investment in the contract at that time.
In plain terms: earnings come out first. If your contract has accumulated more in value than you contributed after tax, withdrawals are taxable until all the earnings have been distributed. Only after the earnings are exhausted does the tax-free return of your investment begin.
IRC § 72(e)(5)(B) provides that contracts entered into before August 14, 1982 follow a different rule — cost comes out first under those older contracts.
Also worth noting: under IRC § 72(e)(4)(A), loans against the contract and assignments or pledges of the contract's value are treated as distributions for this purpose. A loan is not automatically tax-free.
Understanding surrender charges is relevant here as well, because the cash value used in the earnings-first calculation is determined without regard to surrender charges, even though a surrender charge may reduce what you actually receive.