The California Department of Insurance (CDI) defines an immediate annuity as one where income payments start within one year of purchase. A deferred annuity is one where income payments start at least one year—and usually many years—in the future. Both types can be purchased with a single premium or a series of premium payments over time.
The CDI uses plain language to draw the line between these two types.
An immediate annuity provides income payments that start within a year after you buy the annuity. The main reason to buy one is to receive a regular income right away in retirement. Once payments begin, you generally cannot take any extra money out of the contract.
A deferred annuity provides income payments that start at least one year—and usually many years—in the future. The main reason to buy a deferred annuity is to have money grow tax-deferred for a period of time before income begins.
Both types share some basic mechanics. The money you pay to buy an annuity is called the premium or principal. You may fund either type with a single lump-sum premium payment, or you may make a series of premium payments over time. The CDI uses both terms—premium and principal—to describe what the buyer puts in.
Understanding this starting point matters before comparing any other feature. A consumer who needs income now is asking a different question than one who wants to set money aside for future retirement income. The structure of the contract follows from that decision.
The Two Periods Inside a Deferred Annuity
Deferred annuities have an internal structure that immediate annuities do not. The CDI describes two distinct periods.
The accumulation period is when your money grows inside the contract. It can last for over ten years. During this time, the money is not paid out as income; it builds up according to the interest method the contract uses.
The annuitization period—sometimes called the amortization period—is when you receive income payments from the annuity. It can last as long as the annuitant's life, and even the life of a beneficiary. The annuitant is the person who receives income payments from the annuity.
A key feature of the accumulation period is tax deferral. The CDI defines tax deferral this way: the money in your annuity grows tax-deferred, meaning you do not pay taxes on it until you begin receiving income payments. This is the primary reason the CDI identifies for buying a deferred annuity.
An immediate annuity has no accumulation period. Payments begin within the first year, so the contract moves directly to the income phase. For a consumer who has already accumulated savings and wants to convert a lump sum into a stream of income, an immediate annuity (SPIA) may be worth examining alongside a deferred option.
How Interest Accumulates: Fixed, Variable, and Indexed Options
Both immediate and deferred annuities can be structured to earn interest in different ways. The CDI describes three main types.
Fixed annuity: Your money earns interest at rates set by the insurance company, or in another way described in the annuity contract. The interest rate may be set for only one year or for up to ten years. A fixed annuity offers a contractual minimum rate, but the CDI cautions consumers to watch for fixed annuities with a minimum interest rate of zero percent. With a zero-percent floor, you will not lose principal, but your money will not grow.
Variable annuity: The insurance company invests your annuity in stocks, bonds, or other investments based on the risk you want to take. If the fund does not do well, you may lose some or all of your investment. Variable annuities carry a different risk profile than fixed contracts and are subject to securities regulation as well as insurance regulation.
Equity-indexed annuity: The interest rate is usually based on a stock market index. You have a minimum interest rate, and the insurance company decides how much above that minimum you receive. A fixed-indexed annuity sits between a fixed and a variable contract in terms of how interest is credited.
The CDI also warns consumers to watch for advertised high interest rates that are not contractually fixed. Some contracts offer a higher rate for the first year only—sometimes called a teaser rate—and the rate decreases after that. The CDI advises asking what the minimum rate is and how long any higher rate lasts.
Surrender Charges and Access to Money in Deferred Annuities
Liquidity—the ability to access your money when you need it—works very differently in a deferred annuity than in an immediate annuity.
A surrender charge is the fee charged if you take money out of a deferred annuity within a certain period, such as ten years. The CDI notes that surrender charges can be high, and that taking money out during the surrender period may leave you with less than the original principal you put in.
The CDI describes the general pattern this way: you cannot take any money out in the first year. After that, you may be able to take out some money without a penalty. If you take more than the allowed amount, the surrender charges apply. More detail on how these charges are structured appears on the surrender charges page.
For an immediate annuity, the situation is different. The CDI states that you usually cannot take any extra money out of an immediate annuity. Once the contract is funded and payments begin, the buyer generally gives up access to the lump sum in exchange for the income stream.
The CDI is direct about the practical implication: if you think you will need access to your money during the accumulation period, a deferred annuity may not be appropriate. The CDI gives a concrete regulatory illustration of an inappropriate sale: selling a deferred annuity to someone who needs home health care and needs the money to pay for that care. That example is offered as a regulatory illustration of a suitability problem, not as advice about any individual reader's situation.
When comparing options, the CDI checklist suggests asking: What is the surrender charge if I take out money early? How long is the surrender charge period? Can I take some money out without paying surrender charges, and if so, how much?
California Minimum Nonforfeiture Protections for Deferred Contracts
California law sets a floor on the value a deferred annuity contract must make available to the policyowner. This protection is called a minimum nonforfeiture amount—the minimum cash surrender value, paid-up annuity value, or death benefit the insurer must provide under the contract.
Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.25 applies to contracts issued on or after January 1, 2006. It establishes minimum nonforfeiture amounts for paid-up annuity, cash surrender, and death benefits available under a deferred annuity contract.
Under that statute, the minimum nonforfeiture amount is calculated by accumulating net considerations at a specified interest rate. Net considerations are defined in the statute as 87.5 percent of the gross considerations (premiums) credited to the contract during a given contract year. An annual contract charge of $50 is deducted in the calculation.
The interest rate used in the calculation is tied to the five-year Constant Maturity Treasury Rate reported by the Federal Reserve, reduced by 125 basis points, subject to a cap of 3 percent per annum and a floor specified in the statute. The statute also addresses equity-indexed contracts and allows for periodic redetermination of the rate under conditions stated in the contract.
Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.2 governs contracts issued before January 1, 2004, and may be applied to certain contracts issued between January 1, 2004, and January 1, 2006. That earlier statute uses different net consideration percentages and a different annual contract charge amount. The two statutes establish distinct frameworks depending on when the contract was issued.
These minimum nonforfeiture rules apply to deferred contracts. Immediate annuities do not have an accumulation period subject to these rules, because there is no cash surrender value to protect once the income stream has begun. For a deeper look at how these statutory floors work, see the minimum nonforfeiture values page.
How Annuity Payments Are Taxed Under Federal Law
When annuity payments begin—whether from an immediate or a deferred contract—federal law determines how much of each payment is included in your gross income. This section describes general federal rules. It is not individual tax advice. A tax professional can address how these rules apply to your specific situation. California tax treatment is not addressed here because the approved sources for this page do not cover it.
IRC § 72(a) states the general rule: gross income includes any amount received as an annuity under an annuity, endowment, or life insurance contract.
IRC § 72(b) provides the exclusion ratio, which limits how much of each payment is taxable. The exclusion ratio works as follows: the portion of each payment that represents a return of the buyer's investment in the contract is excluded from gross income. The ratio is the investment in the contract as of the annuity starting date divided by the expected return under the contract as of that date.
In plain terms: if a portion of what you paid into the annuity has already been taxed, you are not taxed on it again when it comes back to you as a payment. The remainder of each payment—the portion that represents earnings—is included in gross income.
The exclusion is limited to the unrecovered investment. Once the full investment in the contract has been recovered through excluded payments, all subsequent payments are fully includable in gross income.
Two contract types affect how this works at the starting point:
- A tax-qualified annuity is purchased with pre-tax dollars. Because no tax was paid on the money going in, the investment in the contract for exclusion-ratio purposes is generally zero, and payments are generally fully taxable.
- A non-tax-qualified annuity is purchased with after-tax dollars. The exclusion ratio applies to recover the after-tax investment over the payment period.
The CDI's definition of tax deferral connects to this: money in a deferred annuity grows without current taxation, but taxes are not permanently avoided—they are deferred until income payments begin. More detail on how annuity payments are taxed appears on the how annuities are taxed page, and the qualified vs. nonqualified page addresses the distinction between contract types.
California Consumer Protections: Licensing, Suitability, and the Free-Look Period
California law and CDI guidance provide several protections that apply when buying any annuity in this state.
Suitability. The CDI Life Insurance Guide states that the law requires insurance agents to ask questions about your financial situation to make sure the annuity you are purchasing is suitable for your needs and circumstances. Insurance companies and agents are prohibited from selling an annuity unless there is a reasonable basis to believe it is suitable based on the information you provide.
Factors the CDI identifies as relevant to suitability include: your age; income; liquidity needs; financial time horizon; intended use of the annuity; the extent to which the annuity will tie up your money; and whether you will need to pay surrender charges to access funds for living expenses or emergencies. The suitability rules page covers this framework in more detail.
Free-look period. California seniors have a 30-day free-look period. The CDI defines this as the right to examine an annuity product and, if not satisfied, return it to the company for a full refund. The contract must include a statement about this right. The CDI's language reads: "This policy may be returned within 30 days from the date you received it for a full refund by returning it to the insurance company or agent who sold you the policy. After the 30 days, cancellation may result in a substantial penalty, known as a surrender charge." The free-look and cancellation page explains how this right works in practice.
Licensing verification. The CDI advises confirming that the insurance company is licensed in California before purchasing. License information is available at www.insurance.ca.gov or by calling 1-800-927-4357. If the company is licensed in California, the annuity may be partially protected by the California Life & Health Insurance Guarantee Association (CALIFEGA).
Who can sell an annuity. The person who sells you an annuity should be a licensed life insurance agent. If you are buying a variable annuity, the seller should also be a registered securities dealer.
Side-by-Side Summary: Key Differences at a Glance
The following table draws together the distinctions covered in this article. No new facts are introduced here.
Immediate Annuity
- When income starts
- Within one year of purchase
- Primary purpose
- Regular income right away in retirement
- Accumulation period
- None
- Annuitization period
- Begins promptly after purchase
- Tax deferral on growth
- Not applicable (no accumulation period)
- Surrender charges
- Generally not applicable
- Access to extra funds
- Generally not available
- Minimum nonforfeiture rules
- Not applicable (no accumulation period)
- Federal tax on payments
- IRC § 72(b) exclusion ratio applies once payments begin
- Premium structure
- Single premium or series of payments
Deferred Annuity
- When income starts
- At least one year later; usually many years later
- Primary purpose
- Tax-deferred growth before income begins
- Accumulation period
- Yes; can exceed ten years
- Annuitization period
- Begins after the accumulation period ends; can last for life
- Tax deferral on growth
- Yes; taxes deferred until payments begin
- Surrender charges
- Apply during the accumulation period; can be high
- Access to extra funds
- Partial withdrawals may be allowed after year one, subject to charges
- Minimum nonforfeiture rules
- Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.25 (contracts issued on or after January 1, 2006); Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.2 (contracts issued before January 1, 2004)
- Federal tax on payments
- IRC § 72(b) exclusion ratio applies once payments begin
- Premium structure
- Single premium or series of payments
| Feature | Immediate Annuity | Deferred Annuity |
|---|
| When income starts | Within one year of purchase | At least one year later; usually many years later |
| Primary purpose | Regular income right away in retirement | Tax-deferred growth before income begins |
| Accumulation period | None | Yes; can exceed ten years |
| Annuitization period | Begins promptly after purchase | Begins after the accumulation period ends; can last for life |
| Tax deferral on growth | Not applicable (no accumulation period) | Yes; taxes deferred until payments begin |
| Surrender charges | Generally not applicable | Apply during the accumulation period; can be high |
| Access to extra funds | Generally not available | Partial withdrawals may be allowed after year one, subject to charges |
| Minimum nonforfeiture rules | Not applicable (no accumulation period) | Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.25 (contracts issued on or after January 1, 2006); Cal. Ins. Code § 10168.2 (contracts issued before January 1, 2004) |
| Federal tax on payments | IRC § 72(b) exclusion ratio applies once payments begin | IRC § 72(b) exclusion ratio applies once payments begin |
| Premium structure | Single premium or series of payments | Single premium or series of payments |
A consumer comparing these two types in more depth may also find the annuity comparison checklist and the SPIA vs. MYGA comparison useful starting points before any conversation with a licensed agent.