Skip to content

Comparison

SPIA vs. MYGA: How Immediate Income Annuities and Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities Differ

Updated
October 30, 2026

Direct answer

You may be weighing two common annuity types: one that turns a lump sum into income right away, and one that lets money grow before income begins. Understanding how each is structured — and what California's insurance regulator says about the rules that govern them — is a useful starting point before any conversation with a licensed agent.

Next step

Review My Annuity Options

Guarantees, income riders, surrender periods and rate terms read against the contract.

Continue

The core difference is timing. A single premium immediate annuity (SPIA) starts income payments within one year of purchase. A multi-year guarantee annuity (MYGA) — a type of fixed deferred annuity — holds money in an accumulation period before income begins, often many years later. The California Department of Insurance (CDI) describes this as the immediate versus deferred distinction.


What Is a Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity (MYGA)?

A multi-year guarantee annuity is a type of fixed deferred annuity. The CDI describes fixed annuities as products where money earns interest at rates set by the insurance company, or in another way described in the annuity contract. The interest rate may be set for only one year or for up to ten years.

The CDI describes the main reason to buy a deferred annuity as having money grow tax-deferred — meaning taxes on the interest earned are postponed until withdrawals are made. A tax professional can explain how deferred taxation applies to a specific situation.

Deferred annuities have two distinct periods. The accumulation period is when money grows; the CDI notes it can last for over ten years. The amortization period — when income payments are received — can last as long as the annuitant's life, and even the life of a beneficiary.

The term "MYGA" is commonly used in the industry to describe a fixed deferred annuity with an interest rate that is contractually fixed for a set number of years. The CDI's guidance on fixed annuities covers the mechanics that apply to this product type.


What Is a Single Premium Immediate Annuity (SPIA)?

A single premium immediate annuity, commonly called a SPIA, is purchased with a single lump-sum payment. Income payments begin within one year of that purchase. The CDI describes the main reason to buy an immediate annuity as getting a regular income right away in retirement.

Once income payments begin, the structure changes significantly. According to the CDI, a policyowner generally cannot take any extra money out after income starts. The premium — also called principal — is converted into a stream of payments rather than remaining as a balance the policyowner can access freely.

Because a SPIA is designed around immediate income, it is structurally different from products built around accumulation. A SPIA is structurally designed for situations where regular income is the primary goal and ongoing lump-sum access to the premium is not anticipated — a distinction a licensed agent can help assess against a specific contract. from this particular contract later.


When Income Starts: The Core Difference

The timing of income is the primary structural difference between these two annuity types.

With an immediate annuity, income starts within one year of purchase. With a deferred annuity, income starts many years later — typically at retirement. The CDI states this distinction directly in its consumer guidance.

This difference shapes nearly every other aspect of how the two products work. A SPIA is built for a policyowner who needs income now. A MYGA is built for a policyowner who wants money to grow and plans to draw income later. Neither product is inherently better; the relevant question is which structure fits the policyowner's actual situation and timeline.


How Each Annuity Earns Interest

A SPIA converts principal into income payments rather than accumulating interest in the traditional sense. The focus is on the payment stream, not on a growing account balance.

A MYGA, as a fixed deferred annuity, earns interest during the accumulation period. The CDI explains that the interest rate is set by the insurance company or as described in the contract, and that rate may be set for only one year or for up to ten years.

The CDI highlights several points that consumers should keep in mind when evaluating how a fixed annuity earns interest:

  • Minimum contractual rate of 0%. The CDI warns that a fixed annuity with a minimum contractual interest rate of zero percent means the policyowner will not lose principal, but the money will not grow either.
  • Advertised high rates. The CDI cautions that if an interest rate shown in an advertisement is not contractually locked in, a consumer cannot count on it.
  • Teaser rates. Some annuities offer a higher contractually fixed interest rate for the first year only. The CDI calls this a teaser rate. The interest goes down after that first year. The CDI advises consumers to ask what the minimum rate is and how long any higher rate lasts.

These points apply to fixed deferred annuities generally. Key terms to examine in a MYGA contract include which rate is contractually fixed, the duration of that rate, and the floor rate after any initial period ends., for how long, and what the floor is after any initial period ends.


Liquidity and Access to Your Money

Liquidity — the ability to access money when needed — differs significantly between these two product types.

With a SPIA, the CDI states that a policyowner generally cannot take any extra money out once income payments begin. The premium has been exchanged for a payment stream.

With a deferred annuity such as a MYGA, the CDI is direct: if a policyowner needs money during the accumulation period, they usually have to pay a penalty called a surrender charge. The CDI states that a policyowner cannot take any money out in the first year. After that, some money may be available without a penalty. But if a policyowner takes out more than is allowed, surrender charges can be high — and the policyowner may end up with less money than they started with.

The CDI's guidance is clear on this point: The CDI notes that consumers who anticipate needing access to their money during the accumulation period may find that a deferred annuity does not fit that need, given the surrender charge structure..

This is one of the most important practical differences between a SPIA and a MYGA. A SPIA offers no lump-sum access but provides predictable income. A MYGA preserves a balance that can eventually be accessed or converted to income, but accessing it early carries real cost. Policyowners weighing annuity liquidity and surrender rules should review their contract terms carefully with a licensed agent.


Premium Payment Structure

Both SPIAs and MYGAs are typically purchased with a single premium — a single lump-sum payment. The CDI notes that the money paid to buy an annuity is also called principal.

The CDI also notes that some annuities allow a series of premium payments over time rather than a single upfront amount. Whether a specific contract is a single-premium or flexible-premium product is governed by the contract terms. A policyowner should confirm which structure applies to any contract they are considering.

For most consumers comparing a SPIA to a MYGA, both products involve committing a lump sum at purchase. That commitment — and what happens to it afterward — is what the rest of the contract terms govern.


What Happens to Your Annuity If You Die?

What happens to an annuity at the policyowner's death depends on the contract and on when death occurs relative to the income start date.

The CDI identifies this as an important question for estate planning. If a policyowner dies before income payments begin, the beneficiary may want to cash in the annuity. The CDI advises consumers to ask their agent whether the beneficiary would have to pay a surrender charge in that situation.

This question is relevant for both product types but is especially significant for a MYGA, where a policyowner may be in a multi-year accumulation period at the time of death. The answer depends on the specific contract. Asking this question before purchasing and requesting written confirmation of the answer are steps the CDI's guidance suggests consumers consider..

Estate and tax questions that arise from annuity death benefits are outside the scope of insurance education. A tax or legal professional can address those aspects.


How California Regulates Annuities

The California Department of Insurance oversees fixed, variable, indexed, immediate, and deferred annuities sold in California. The CDI publishes consumer guidance specifically for seniors, including the guide Annuities: What Seniors Need to Know, which is the source for the product descriptions and consumer warnings throughout this article.

California consumers can contact the CDI at 800-927-4357 or visit insurance.ca.gov for additional guidance. The CDI does not sell annuities or recommend products; it provides oversight and consumer education.

Any annuity sold in California must be sold by a licensed agent. A consumer can verify a California insurance license at the CDI's website.


Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing

The CDI's guidance suggests several questions a consumer should raise with a licensed agent before purchasing either type of annuity. These questions apply whether the product under consideration is a SPIA or a MYGA:

  1. What is the minimum contractual interest rate, and how long does any higher rate last? This is especially important for a MYGA, where a teaser rate may apply only in the first year.
  2. What are the surrender charges, and during which period do they apply? The CDI warns that surrender charges can be high and can leave a policyowner with less than they started with.
  3. When will income payments begin, and how long will they last? The answer differs fundamentally between a SPIA (within one year) and a MYGA (many years later, potentially for life).
  4. What happens to the annuity if I die before income payments start? The CDI identifies this as an important estate-planning question. Ask whether a surrender charge would apply to the beneficiary.
  5. Will I need access to this money during the accumulation period? The CDI advises that if the answer is yes, a deferred annuity is not appropriate.

These questions do not produce a recommendation on their own. They are a starting framework for a conversation with a licensed agent who can review the specific contract terms and the policyowner's situation.

In confidence

You Don’t Have to Work This Out Alone

Every policy and every family is different. Call or send us a message, and we’ll listen and help you see the questions to ask about your own coverage.

LifeInsuranceAdvisor.co

What happens next

  1. Call or send a messageWhichever feels easier.
  2. Tell us what’s going onIn confidence, in your own words.
  3. Talk through your optionsThen decide, in your own time, what comes next.

Common questions

What is the main difference between a SPIA and a MYGA?

A SPIA starts income payments within one year of purchase. A MYGA is a type of fixed deferred annuity where money grows during an accumulation period before income begins. The CDI describes this as the immediate versus deferred distinction — the timing of when income starts is the primary structural difference between the two product types.

Can I take money out of a MYGA before the accumulation period ends?

Generally not without a potential cost. The CDI states that a policyowner cannot take any money out in the first year of a deferred annuity. After that, limited withdrawals may be available without a penalty. However, if a policyowner takes out more than is allowed, surrender charges can be high, and the policyowner may end up with less money than they started with. The CDI's guidance indicates that deferred annuities carry surrender charges that may make them unsuitable for consumers who anticipate needing liquidity during the accumulation period — a factor a licensed agent can help evaluate..

Is a MYGA the same as a fixed annuity?

A MYGA is a type of fixed deferred annuity. The CDI describes fixed annuities as products where money earns interest at rates set by the insurance company or as described in the contract, with the rate potentially fixed for one to ten years. The term "MYGA" is commonly used in the industry to describe a fixed deferred annuity with a multi-year contractually fixed rate; the CDI's guidance on fixed and deferred annuities covers the mechanics that apply.

What is a teaser rate on an annuity?

The CDI describes a teaser rate as a higher contractually fixed interest rate offered for the first year of an annuity only. The interest rate goes down after that first year. The CDI advises consumers to ask what the minimum rate is and how long any higher rate lasts before purchasing.

Does California have any specific rules about annuities sold to seniors?

The California Department of Insurance publishes guidance specifically for seniors, including the guide Annuities: What Seniors Need to Know, which covers product types, interest mechanics, surrender charges, and consumer warnings. The CDI can be reached at 800-927-4357 or at insurance.ca.gov.

What happens to my annuity if I die before income payments begin?

The CDI identifies this as an important estate-planning question. If a policyowner dies before income payments start, the beneficiary may want to cash in the annuity. The CDI advises consumers to ask their agent whether the beneficiary would have to pay a surrender charge in that situation. The answer depends on the specific contract terms.

Related guides

Talk to someone

Prefer to talk it through?

(888) 601-3119Schedule a Conversation

Sources & citations

1 official source

  1. [1]California Department of Insurance, Annuities: What Seniors Need to KnowCalifornia Department of Insurance

Published by LifeInsuranceAdvisor.co

Call UsMessage UsChat