A fixed annuity credits interest at a rate declared by the insurer and stated in the contract. A fixed indexed annuity credits interest based on the performance of a stock market index, but the insurer determines how much of any index gain the contract holder actually receives, and the consumer will not receive all of the extra interest the stock market might earn. Both types carry a contractually stated minimum interest rate, which the California Department of Insurance notes can be as low as zero percent.
What Is a Fixed Annuity?
A fixed annuity is a contract in which your money earns interest at rates set by the insurance company, or in another way described in the annuity contract. The California Department of Insurance (CDI) explains that the interest rate may be set for only one year or for up to ten years.
The contractually stated minimum interest rate in a fixed annuity sets a floor on what you earn. The CDI specifically warns consumers to watch out for fixed annuities with a minimum stated interest rate of zero percent. At that floor, you will not lose principal, but your money will not grow.
One additional feature to understand is the teaser rate. Some fixed annuities offer a higher stated interest rate for the first year only. The CDI calls this a teaser rate and notes that the interest goes down after that period. The CDI recommends that consumers ask about the minimum rate and the duration of any elevated rate prior to purchasing a fixed annuity.
For a closer look at how fixed annuities work on their own, the fixed annuity overview covers the mechanics in more detail.
What Is a Fixed Indexed Annuity?
A fixed indexed annuity — referred to in the CDI guide as an equity-indexed annuity — has an interest rate that is usually based on a stock market index. This distinguishes it from a plain fixed annuity, where the rate is simply declared by the insurer.
Like a fixed annuity, a fixed indexed annuity carries a contractually stated minimum interest rate. The CDI describes these minimums as conservative. The interest you earn might be higher than that minimum, but it is not certain.
The critical point the CDI emphasizes: the insurance company decides how much of the index gain the contract holder receives. You will not get all the extra interest the stock market might earn. This means a fixed indexed annuity is not a direct investment in the stock market. The index is used as a measuring tool; the insurer sets the terms for how gains are translated into credited interest.
The CDI also cautions consumers about advertisements showing high interest rates. If the interest rate shown is not contractually fixed, you cannot count on receiving it.
How Interest Crediting Differs Between the Two Types
The practical difference between these two annuity types comes down to how interest is calculated and applied to your account each period.
Fixed annuity — declared rate. The insurer states a specific interest rate in the contract. That rate applies for the period described, whether one year or up to ten years. You know in advance what rate your money will earn during that period.
Fixed indexed annuity — index-linked rate. The interest credited is tied to the movement of a stock market index over a measurement period. However, the insurer determines how much of any index gain is passed along to the contract holder. The CDI is clear that you will not receive all of the extra interest the stock market might earn.
Both types carry a contractually stated minimum interest rate. The CDI notes that this minimum can be as low as zero percent for either type. At zero percent, principal is not lost, but the account does not grow.
Neither type is a direct investment in the stock market. A variable annuity — a different product the CDI addresses separately — is the type that invests in market funds and can result in loss of principal. Fixed and fixed indexed annuities do not work that way.
A multi-year guarantee annuity is a variation of the fixed annuity that locks in a declared rate for a set number of years; that structure is covered separately.
Guarantees and Principal Protection
Both fixed and fixed indexed annuities offer a form of principal protection that distinguishes them from variable annuities.
With a fixed annuity, the CDI states that even at a zero percent minimum stated rate, you will not lose principal. The trade-off is that your money does not grow at that floor.
With a fixed indexed annuity, a contractually stated minimum interest rate also exists. The CDI describes these minimums as conservative. Interest above the minimum is possible but not assured, because the insurer controls how much index gain is credited.
Neither type exposes the contract holder to direct market loss the way a variable annuity does. The CDI explains that with a variable annuity, if the fund does not do well, you may lose some or all of your investment. That risk profile is different from what fixed and fixed indexed annuities carry.
One area where consumers can end up with less money than they started with is surrender charges during the accumulation period — covered in the next section.
The CDI also warns about advertising: if an interest rate shown in any advertisement is not contractually fixed, you cannot count on it. This applies to both types.
Surrender Charges and Access to Money
Both fixed and fixed indexed annuities are typically structured as deferred contracts, meaning your money grows over an accumulation period before income payments begin. The CDI describes deferred annuities as long-term investments, with an accumulation period that can last for over ten years.
During the accumulation period, withdrawing money usually triggers a surrender charge — a penalty for taking money out early. The CDI warns that surrender charges can be high and that you may end up with less money than you started with if you withdraw during this period.
After the first year, some contracts allow a limited withdrawal without penalty. The CDI notes that after the first year, you may be able to take out some money without a penalty, but taking more than that amount can trigger the charge.
The CDI is direct about suitability: The CDI notes that deferred annuities may not be appropriate for consumers who anticipate needing access to their funds during the accumulation period.
California law and senior citizens. California Insurance Code section 10127.13 places a specific requirement on annuity contracts sold to senior citizens. All individual annuity contracts for senior citizens that contain a charge upon surrender, partial surrender, excess withdrawal, or penalties upon surrender must contain a notice disclosing the location of the charge, the charge time period, the charge information, and any associated penalty information. That notice must be in bold 12-point type on the front of the policy jacket or on the cover page of the policy.
Beneficiary consideration. The CDI raises an important estate-planning question: if you die before income payments begin, your beneficiary may want to cash in the annuity. The CDI identifies this as an important estate-planning question: whether a beneficiary would owe a surrender charge if the contract holder dies before income payments begin.
Both fixed and fixed indexed annuities can be structured as either immediate or deferred contracts. The payout structure is a separate decision from the interest-crediting method.
Immediate annuity. The CDI explains that with an immediate annuity, income payments begin within one year after purchase. You usually cannot take any extra money out. The main reason to buy an immediate annuity, according to the CDI, is to receive a regular income right away in retirement.
Deferred annuity. With a deferred annuity, income payments begin many years later. The CDI identifies the main reason to choose a deferred structure: to have your money grow tax-deferred (meaning no income tax is owed on the growth until you withdraw it) during the accumulation period.
The CDI defines the two phases of a deferred annuity clearly. The accumulation period is when your money grows; it can last for over ten years. The amortization period is when you receive income payments; it can last as long as your life, and even the life of your beneficiary.
Understanding which structure a contract uses matters when comparing a fixed annuity to a fixed indexed annuity, because both types can appear in either form. The deferred annuity overview and the income annuity overview address those structures in more detail.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing Between the Two Types
The CDI guide points to several questions that consumers should raise with a licensed agent before purchasing either type of annuity. These questions apply whether you are comparing contracts for the first time or reviewing one you already hold.
About the interest rate and guarantees: - What is the minimum stated interest rate, and how long does any higher introductory rate last? The CDI specifically flags teaser rates — elevated first-year rates that decrease afterward. - For a fixed indexed annuity: how does the insurer determine how much of the index gain is credited to the contract? The CDI notes that the insurer makes this determination, and the consumer will not receive all of the index gain. - Is the interest rate shown in any advertisement actually contractually fixed? The CDI warns that if it is not, you cannot count on it.
About access to your money: - What are the surrender charges, how long do they last, and what is the free-withdrawal amount after the first year? - If you die before income payments begin, would your beneficiary owe a surrender charge? The CDI identifies this as an important estate-planning question.
For consumers who already hold an annuity and want to understand what their contract actually says, an existing annuity review looks at the specific terms of the contract in hand.