California law requires that illustrations not mislead purchasers and that they present information in a format a typical consumer can follow. Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.950 states the Legislature's intent: to ensure illustrations do not mislead purchasers of life insurance and to make illustrations more understandable by providing illustration formats, prescribing standards, and specifying required disclosures.
What a Life Insurance Sales Illustration Is
An illustration is a series of numbers showing how the policy works, according to the California Department of Insurance Life Insurance Guide. It typically shows both the fixed, contractual results under the policy for each future year and the results if all non-fixed items continue at their present level.
The CDI guide makes one point worth reading twice: actual results may be better or worse than the non-fixed amounts shown in the illustration, but not worse than the contractual amounts. That distinction—between what the policy contractually promises and what it projects under current assumptions—runs through every section of a compliant illustration.
California Insurance Code Chapter 10509.950 et seq. governs illustration regulation. Its stated purpose is protecting consumers, fostering consumer education, and ensuring illustrations do not mislead purchasers of life insurance.
The Three Types of Illustrations California Law Recognizes
Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.953(h) defines three distinct illustration types. Knowing which one you are looking at matters.
Basic illustration. A ledger or proposal used in the sale of a life insurance policy that shows both fixed and non-fixed elements (§ 10509.953(h)(1)). This is the document most consumers receive from an agent before or at the time of application.
Supplemental illustration. An illustration furnished in addition to a basic illustration (§ 10509.953(h)(2)). It may use a different format, but it may only depict a scale of non-fixed elements that is permitted in a basic illustration. A supplemental illustration does not replace the basic illustration.
In-force illustration. An illustration furnished at any time after the policy has been in force for one year or more (§ 10509.953(h)(3)). If you already own a policy and want to see how it is currently projected to perform, an in-force illustration is the relevant document.
Every illustration, regardless of type, must be clearly labeled "life insurance illustration" (§ 10509.955(a)).
Fixed Versus Non-Fixed Elements: The Core Distinction
This distinction is the foundation of every illustration. California law defines both terms precisely.
Fixed elements are the premiums, benefits, values, credits, or charges under a policy that are fixed and determined at policy issue (§ 10509.953(f)). These are the contractual commitments the insurer makes at the time the policy is issued. They cannot be changed by the insurer after issue.
Non-fixed elements are the premiums, benefits, values, credits, or charges that are not fixed or not determined at issue (§ 10509.953(m)). These may include credited interest rates, dividend scales, or cost-of-insurance charges that the insurer can adjust over time. Whole life insurance and universal life insurance policies both involve non-fixed elements, though the specific elements differ by policy type.
California law imposes several requirements on how these two categories are presented:
- Fixed elements must be shown before corresponding non-fixed elements and clearly labeled (§ 10509.956(a)(8)).
- Non-fixed elements must be clearly labeled as such and cannot be based on a scale more favorable than the insurer's illustrated scale at any duration (§ 10509.956(a)(7)).
- Any illustration of non-fixed elements must be accompanied by a statement that the benefits and values are not fixed, that the assumptions are subject to change by the insurer, and that actual results may be more or less favorable (§ 10509.956(a)(12)).
What a Basic Illustration Must Contain Under California Law
Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.956 sets out the required contents in detail. A consumer reviewing a basic illustration should be able to find each of the following.
Identification and labeling. The illustration must be labeled with the date it was prepared. Every page, including explanatory notes, must be numbered showing its relationship to the total number of pages (§ 10509.956(a)(1)–(2)). The document must also identify the insurer's name, the producer's name and business address, the proposed insured's name, age, and sex, the underwriting classification, the generic policy name, the form number, and the initial death benefit (§ 10509.955(a)(1)–(7)).
Narrative summary. The basic illustration must include (§ 10509.956(b)):
- A brief description of the policy, including a statement that it is a life insurance policy
- A brief description of the premium outlay or contract premium
- A brief description of any features or riders shown and their potential impact on benefits and values
- Definitions of column headings and key terms
- The following statutory statement: "This illustration assumes that the currently illustrated nonguaranteed elements will continue unchanged for all years shown. This is not likely to occur, and actual results may be more or less favorable than those shown."
Numeric summary on three bases. Following the narrative, the illustration must include a numeric summary showing death benefits, values, and premiums for at least policy years 5, 10, and 20 and at age 70 (if applicable), presented on three separate bases (§ 10509.956(c)(1)):
- Policy contractual terms — what the policy contractually promises regardless of how non-fixed elements perform
- Insurer's full illustrated scale — the projection using current non-fixed element assumptions
- Illustrated scale with non-fixed elements reduced — a middle-ground scenario using reduced dividends, averaged credited interest rates, and averaged non-fixed charges
This three-column structure is one of the most consumer-protective features of California's illustration rules. It prevents a presentation that shows only the most optimistic projection.
Tabular detail. The illustration must show year-by-year data for at least each policy year from 1 through 10 and for every fifth year thereafter through age 100, policy maturity, or final expiration (§ 10509.956(e)(1)).
What Insurers and Agents Are Prohibited From Doing
Cal. Ins. Code § 10509.955(b) lists specific conduct that is prohibited when an illustration is used in a sale. Consumers who recognize these practices can ask questions or request a corrected illustration.
- Misrepresenting the policy type. An insurer or producer cannot represent the policy as anything other than a life insurance policy (§ 10509.955(b)(1)).
- Misleading use of non-fixed elements. They cannot use or describe non-fixed elements in a misleading manner or imply that non-fixed elements are fixed (§ 10509.955(b)(2)–(3)).
- Overly favorable projections. They cannot use an illustration that at any policy duration depicts performance more favorable than that produced by the insurer's own illustrated scale (§ 10509.955(b)(5)).
- Incomplete illustrations. They cannot provide an applicant with an incomplete illustration (§ 10509.955(b)(6)).
- "Vanishing premium" language. They cannot use the term "vanishing" or "vanishing premium," or similar language implying the policy becomes paid up, to describe a plan for using non-fixed elements to pay future premiums (§ 10509.955(b)(8)). Because non-fixed elements can be reduced by the insurer, a projection showing premiums "disappearing" based on current non-fixed assumptions may not hold. This prohibition exists precisely because consumers have historically been misled by such presentations.
- Lapse-supported illustrations. They cannot use an illustration that is lapse-supported (§ 10509.955(b)(9)). A lapse-supported illustration is one that appears sustainable only because it assumes a portion of policyowners will lapse their policies, freeing up funds to support those who remain. California law requires illustrations to be self-supporting (§ 10509.955(b)(10)).
Signatures and Delivery: Your Rights at Application and Policy Delivery
California law creates specific obligations around when you receive an illustration and what you sign. These rules apply whether you are buying term life insurance or a permanent policy.
When a basic illustration is used and the policy is applied for as illustrated. A signed copy of the illustration must be submitted to the insurer at the time of application, and a copy must be provided to you as the applicant (§ 10509.958(a)(1)).
When the policy is issued differently from what was applied for. If the insurer issues the policy on different terms than illustrated—for example, at a different underwriting classification—a revised basic illustration labeled "Revised Illustration" must be sent with the policy. It must be signed no later than the time of policy delivery (§ 10509.958(a)(2)).
When no illustration is used. If the producer does not use an illustration, they must certify that in writing. The applicant must also acknowledge in writing that no conforming illustration was provided and that one will be delivered with the policy (§ 10509.958(b)(1)).
Dual signature statements. The numeric summary page of a basic illustration includes two statements that must be signed (§ 10509.956(d)):
- Your statement acknowledges that you received a copy of the illustration, that non-fixed elements are subject to change and could be higher or lower, and that the agent has told you they are not fixed.
- The producer's statement certifies that the illustration was presented to you and that no statements inconsistent with the illustration were made.
Record retention. The insurer must retain a copy of the signed illustration until three years after the policy is no longer in force (§ 10509.958(d)). This means a record of what was shown to you at the point of sale exists for the life of the policy and beyond.
Using Index Numbers to Compare Policies
An illustration shows how one specific policy is projected to work. When comparing multiple policies, the California Department of Insurance Life Insurance Guide recommends using index numbers developed to aid shopping. The CDI guide states that your chances of finding a good buy on a life insurance policy are better if you use these index numbers.
Each insurer is required to provide a Buyer's Guide to a purchaser. The Buyer's Guide explains these index numbers in detail. The CDI guide describes them as good tools to help compare the merits of similar policies.
The illustration and the Buyer's Guide are intended to be used together. The illustration shows the mechanics and projections for a specific policy; the index numbers help place that policy in context relative to similar options. If you have not received a Buyer's Guide alongside your illustration, you are entitled to ask for one.
The Role of the Illustration Actuary and the Disciplined Current Scale
Non-fixed element projections in an illustration are not arbitrary. California law establishes a regulatory ceiling on how favorable those projections can be.
The disciplined current scale is a scale of non-fixed elements constituting a limit on illustrations, reasonably based on actual recent historical experience, certified annually by an illustration actuary designated by the insurer (§ 10509.953(d)). An illustration actuary is an actuary who certifies illustrations based on actuarial standards of practice.
The illustrated scale—the scale actually used in the illustration—cannot be more favorable to the policy owner than the lesser of the disciplined current scale or the currently payable scale (§ 10509.953(g)).
The currently payable scale is the scale of non-fixed elements in effect as of the illustration preparation date or declared to become effective within the next 95 days (§ 10509.953(c)).
In plain terms: the insurer cannot illustrate non-fixed elements at levels more optimistic than what it is actually crediting or charging today, and those current levels must themselves be supportable by recent historical experience as certified by a qualified actuary. If an interest rate is shown to determine illustrated non-fixed elements, it cannot exceed the earned interest rate underlying the disciplined current scale (§ 10509.955(c)).
This actuarial backstop is why the illustrated scale in a compliant illustration represents a reasonable—though not fixed—projection rather than a best-case scenario. A policy review of an existing policy can compare what was originally illustrated against how non-fixed elements have actually performed.