California Insurance Code § 10160 requires that every qualifying life insurance policy delivered or issued in California contain nonforfeiture provisions at least as favorable as the statutory minimums. If a policyowner misses a premium and takes no action within 60 days, the policy's automatic default option takes effect—preserving some coverage rather than ending the policy entirely.
What Are Nonforfeiture Options?
The California Department of Insurance defines nonforfeiture options as "a provision in the policy that allows the policy owner to choose how the cash value of the policy will be used if the policy is surrendered or lapses due to nonpayment of premium" (CDI Life Insurance Guide, glossary).
These provisions apply to cash value (permanent) life insurance policies. Pure term policies, which build no cash value, are not subject to the same requirements. The practical effect is that a policyowner who stops paying premiums on a whole life or universal life policy retains contractual rights to the value that has accumulated—rather than forfeiting it entirely.
California Insurance Code § 10160 states that, except as provided in Section 10165, no life insurance policy may be delivered or issued in California unless it contains nonforfeiture provisions at least as favorable as the statutory minimums.
When Do Nonforfeiture Options Become Available?
The right to elect a nonforfeiture option depends on how long premiums have been paid and which benefit the policyowner is requesting.
For a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit, the right arises after premiums have been paid for at least one full year. A proper request must be made not later than 60 days after the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(a)). That 60-day window is a firm deadline; policyowners who are uncertain about continuing payments should act promptly.
For a cash surrender value, the right arises after premiums have been paid for at least three full years in the case of ordinary insurance, or five full years in the case of industrial insurance. The policyowner must surrender the policy within 60 days after the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(b)).
If no election is made within the applicable window, a specified paid-up nonforfeiture benefit becomes effective automatically, as described in the section below (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(c)).
The Three Core Nonforfeiture Options
California law recognizes three primary ways a policyowner can apply accumulated cash value when premiums stop:
Reduced paid-up insurance keeps the policy in force for the insured's lifetime, but with a lower death benefit than the original. No further premium payments are required.
Extended term insurance keeps the original death benefit amount in force, but only for a fixed period determined by how far the cash value will stretch. No further premium payments are required.
Cash surrender value ends the policy entirely. The insurer pays the policyowner the accumulated cash value, and coverage ceases.
California Insurance Code § 10160 requires the policy itself to state which of these options applies automatically if the policyowner makes no election within the 60-day window.
Reduced Paid-Up Insurance: How It Works
When a policyowner elects reduced paid-up insurance, the accumulated cash value is applied as a single premium to purchase a paid-up policy of the same type as the original. The death benefit is lower than the original face amount, but coverage continues for the life of the insured without any further premium payments.
The present value of the paid-up nonforfeiture benefit must be at least equal to the cash surrender value at the time of default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10162). This statutory floor means the policyowner receives a benefit whose value is linked to what they could have taken in cash.
In some cases, an insurer may substitute an actuarially equivalent alternative paid-up nonforfeiture benefit that provides a greater amount or longer period of death benefits, upon proper request not later than 60 days after the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(a)).
Extended Term Insurance: How It Works
When a policyowner elects extended term insurance, the cash value is used to purchase term insurance equal to the original face amount. Coverage continues at the full original death benefit for as long a period as the cash value will support.
The paid-up nonforfeiture benefit is effective as of the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(a)). When a premium default occurs at a time other than a policy anniversary, values are calculated with allowance for the lapse of time and the payment of fractional premiums beyond the last preceding policy anniversary (Cal. Ins. Code § 10164).
One important distinction from reduced paid-up insurance: extended term coverage ends when the fixed period expires. A policyowner who lives beyond that period would no longer have coverage in force. Reviewing an in-force illustration can help clarify how long the extended term period would last under current policy values.
The Automatic (Default) Nonforfeiture Option
If a policyowner takes no action within the election window, a specified paid-up nonforfeiture benefit becomes effective automatically, unless another available option is elected not later than 60 days after the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(c)).
The policy document itself states which option serves as the automatic default. Many policies designate extended term insurance as the automatic option, but this varies by contract. Policyowners should review their policy schedule or contact their insurer directly to confirm which option applies to their specific policy.
Understanding the automatic option matters because a policyowner who does nothing is not left without coverage—but the coverage that takes effect may not align with their current needs. Awareness of this mechanism is one reason a periodic existing policy review is worth scheduling.
How California Law Sets the Minimum Value of Each Option
California law establishes a statutory floor for both cash surrender values and paid-up nonforfeiture benefits. These floors protect policyowners from receiving less than the law requires.
The cash surrender value must be at least the excess of the present value of future contractual benefits over the present value of adjusted future premiums, less any policy indebtedness (Cal. Ins. Code § 10161). In plain terms, the insurer cannot pay out less than the actuarial value of what the policy would have provided, net of what remains owed.
Any paid-up nonforfeiture benefit must have a present value at least equal to the cash surrender value at the time of default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10162). The two values are linked by statute.
Every qualifying policy must include a schedule showing cash surrender values and paid-up nonforfeiture benefits for each policy anniversary during the first 20 years or the policy term, whichever is shorter (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(e)). The policy must also include a brief statement of the method used to calculate values beyond the last anniversary shown in that schedule (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(f)). Policyowners can find this schedule in their policy documents; it is a useful starting point for understanding what each option would provide.
What Riders and Add-On Benefits Are Not Included
Many cash value policies include supplemental riders—such as accidental death or dismemberment coverage, total and permanent disability benefits, reversionary annuity benefits, and certain term insurance riders. These additional benefits are disregarded when calculating cash surrender values and nonforfeiture benefits (Cal. Ins. Code § 10164). No such additional benefits are required to be included in any paid-up nonforfeiture benefit.
This means a policyowner who elects reduced paid-up or extended term insurance should not expect those riders to continue automatically. Reviewing the policy documents carefully—or requesting a summary from the insurer—will clarify which, if any, supplemental benefits remain in force under a given nonforfeiture option. Questions about policy loans and other features that may interact with rider provisions are worth raising during that review.
Nonforfeiture Options vs. Surrendering the Policy
The most significant practical difference between nonforfeiture options and a cash surrender is this: surrendering for cash ends the policy entirely, while reduced paid-up and extended term insurance keep some death benefit in force.
The CDI Life Insurance Guide cautions that replacing or changing a policy may affect the intended results of an overall financial plan, and that policyowners should assess their needs and long-term interests before making changes (CDI Life Insurance Guide, "Facts If You Are Considering Changes to Your Life Insurance Policy"). The Guide also notes that a policyowner may have the ability to amend or convert a current policy to a newer product within the same insurer without loss of rights or accumulated cash value.
These cautions apply equally when a policyowner is weighing a nonforfeiture election against a full surrender. The decision involves the policyowner's current coverage needs, the policy's remaining value, and any other financial considerations—none of which this page can evaluate for an individual reader. A tax or legal professional can address any tax consequences that may arise from a surrender. For context on what a full surrender involves, see surrendering a life insurance policy.
One additional procedural note: the insurer reserves the right to defer payment of any cash surrender value for up to six months after demand (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160).
How to Elect a Nonforfeiture Option in California
The process for electing a nonforfeiture option follows the timelines set by statute. For a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit, a proper request must be made not later than 60 days after the due date of the premium in default (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(a)). For a cash surrender, the surrender must occur within 60 days after the due date of the premium in default, provided the applicable minimum years of premium payment have been met (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(b)).
For a policy that has already become paid up—or that is being continued under a paid-up nonforfeiture benefit that became effective on or after the third policy anniversary for ordinary insurance, or the fifth for industrial insurance—the policyowner may surrender for cash value within 30 days after any policy anniversary (Cal. Ins. Code § 10160(d)).
Policyowners should contact their insurer in writing and retain documentation of the request and its effective date. If there is uncertainty about which option is available or what the current cash value is, requesting a current policy performance statement from the insurer is a practical first step. Understanding the risk of policy lapse is also relevant for anyone approaching the end of a grace period.